the key figure in he deal from the Packer end. The Lions were reluctant to part with him, but Blackbourn insisted that he be included or there would be no deal and Detroit finally agreed to the condition late Thursday afternoon. An All-American at Michigan State in 1955, Masters was the Chicago Cardinals’ No. 2 choice in the 1956 collegiate draft. He elected to play at Vancouver last fall, however, and the Cards traded him to Detroit over the winter for what was described as “a very high draft choice.” Packer officials checked with Vancouver’s coaches and they rated the 6-foot, 2-inch 245 giant “very high, both as an offensive and defensive tackle.” Lion Coach Buddy Parker said he was “happy” to have Rote, key figure in the 24-21 Thanksgiving Day victory that knocked Detroit out of the 1956 Western Division championship, on his side. The Lions have two QB’s, Bobby Layne and Jerry Reichow, but Layne has been plagued with a bad shoulder and Reichow has had little experience. Rote, who led the NFL in touchdown pitches last year with 18, ranks as the Packers’ all-time passer – a major distinction considering he followed such Green Bay immortals as Arnie Herber and Cecil Isbell. The Rice Rifle, as he has come to be known, completed 826 of 1,854 passes for 11,535 yards and 89 touchdowns during his seven years as the Packers’ air arm. Last year, in addition to leading the league in TD passes, he also threw more passes (308) and gained more air yards (2,203) than any other NFL QB. He also had the least number intercepted percentagewise. Among other Packer records held by Rote are most passes completed in one season, 180; most passes attempted in one season, 382; most attempts one game, 42, against the Chicago Bears, Nov. 7, 1954; most yards gained on passes in one season, 2,311 in 1954; most yards gained on passes one game, 335, against the Los Angeles Rams Dec. 16, 1951; longest completed pass, 96 yards (to Billy Grimes vs. San Francisco, 1950); and most passes had intercepted one season, 24, as a rookie in 1950. “I not only think Rote is a great player,” Blackbourn said, “but he is the greatest competitor that ever played under me. I hated very much to let him go.” As of now, Blackbourn said, sophomore Bart Starr, who understudied Rote last year, “is my No. 1 quarterback until someone shows me otherwise.” Besides Starr, Blackbourn has Babe Parilli, obtained in that trade with Cleveland, and Notre Dame All America Paul Hornung. “We couldn’t afford the luxury of four quarterbacks. As it stands, we’ll probably only have two – Starr and Parilli – because Hornung will alternate between quarterback and left halfback,” Blackbourn said. Walker, a four-year veteran, is regarded as one of the league’s premier defensive backs. Obtained in a trade from the New York Giants in 1953, he has officially been regarded as a holdout this season. Blackbourn and his aides, as a matter of fact, were operating under the assumption that the slight Southern Methodist alumnus, who intercepted one pass in 1956, would not return, since he was not listed on the training camp roster.
'I SURE HATE TO GO', ROTE; VAL MAY QUIT
JUL 26 (Green Bay) - Tobin Rote, who arrived in Green Bay Thursday night ready to launch his eighth season as a Packer, today was “still shocked” over finding himself a Detroit Lion. “It’s sure going to be funny playing against the Packers after spending all these years in Green Bay,” the big Texan drawled. “I sure hate to go.” Rote said that Detroit is the “only other team I would play for. If I had been traded to anyone else, I think I would have packed my bags and called it quits.” After recovering from the initial shock, Tobin set about making arrangements to join the Lions, already training at their suburban Detroit base. He will leave Green Bay Saturday noon. In Dallas, Val Joe Walker, the other Packer principal in the trade, said he did not plan to play pro football this season. “I told Buddy Parker (Detroit coach) over the telephone Thursday and again Thursday night that I didn’t intend to play this season,” Walker said. “But, Parker told me if I changed my mind to let him know.” Walker said he planned to stay in insurance here in Dallas.
PACKERS TRADE ROTE TO LIONS; GET 4 PLAYERS
JULY 26 (Detroit) - The Detroit Lions and Green Bay Packers have completed a six-player trade that brings quarterback Tobin Rote and defensive halfback Val Joe Walker to the Detroit club. The Packers in turn receive linemen Jim Salsbury, Oliver Spencer and Norm Masters, along with sophomore halfback Don McIlhenny. Word of the deal leaked out late Thursday night when Detroit coach Buddy Parker called Rote's home in Bellaire, Tex., to inform Rote of the trade. But Rote, a seven-year veteran who led the NFL in nearly every passing department last season, was already on his way to the Packer training camp in Stevens Point, Wis. Although the Packers, who finished tied for last in the Western Conference last season, needed help in the line, it was a startling transaction from the Detroit viewpoint. Rote, 29-year old former Rice star who threw 18 touchdown passes in 1956, will join another Texan, Bobby Layne, and second year man Jerry Reichow in the Detroit quarterback spot. Layne, 30, has been in the pro ranks nine years and a Lion mainstay seven seasons. Over the past three years he has been troubled by a shoulder ailment but last season he was one of the league's top passers, and led the NFL in scoring with 99 points. Walker is a 27-year old former SMU player. The Lions said he has announced his retirement. If he can't be talked out of it, the Detroit club will get a 1958 draft choice. The Lions parted with three proven linemen and a promising halfback. Salsbury played two seasons as an offensive guard. Spencer won the job as an offensive tackle as a rookie in 1953, completed two years in service and returned in 1956 to reclaim his old job. Masters, former Michigan State star, played last year in Canada and only recently was obtained by the Lions in a complicated trade with the Chicago Cardinals, who drafted him originally in 1956. McIlhenny is another former Southern Methodist back. He scored five touchdowns and averaged 4.3 yards in 87 carries last season, but was injured midway through the season and never regained his early-season effectiveness. At Green Bay, Coach Lisle Blackbourn said the trade was made because of heavy losses to the armed services and retirement. "We were desperately in need of offensive linemen," Blackbourn said. "In order to get enough we had to sacrifice one of the finest quarterbacks in the league."
DOESN'T PLAN TO PLAY
JULY 26 (Dallas) - Val Joe Walker, star defensive back who was traded along with Tobin Rote to the Detroit Lions by the Green Bay Packers, said today he did not plan to play pro football this season. "I told Buddy Parker (Detroit coach) over the telephone Thursday and again Thursday night that I didn't intend to play this season," Walker said. "But, Parker told me that I changed my mind to let him know." Walker, a former SMU hurdler and backfield star, said he planned to stay in insurance here in Dallas. He had been with Green Bay four years.
CITY STADIUM NAME CHOSEN FOR NEW SITE
JUL 27 (Green Bay) - It’s official now. The new municipal stadium will have the name of Green Bay City Stadium after more often than not being referred to as “the new city stadium” since construction started. The name was made official by the Stadium Commission Friday, when Mayor Otto Rachals advised the group that a committee planning a dedication program needs a definite name for advance publicity. The commission decided the name would best illustrate the ownership and source of financing for the stadium…NEW NAME FOR OLD: For persons fussy about such things, however, the step means that a new name also will have to be given to present City Stadium, which is operated by the Board of Education. The commission also set August 16 as a target for opening of bids for the stadium concessions for the contract for the fall season and August 5 for releasing of specifications and qualifications for the contract. The group asked City Attorney Clarence Nier, commission president, to write the specifications. A decision on whether to get bids based on a flat offer, a percentage of gross, or both methods will made at a session August 2. As a result of an inspection of facilities at Milwaukee County Stadium Thursday, the commission authorized change orders to move back a fence under the stands to provide more room and to extend utilities to more concession stands. The stadium would have six stands with all utilities and two without sewer, water and gas…CHANGES AUTHORIZED: The commission approved payment of $1,633 for a previous change order for guide rails and asked its construction committee to determine the cost of lockers for the team’s building or whether equipment could be moved from the present stadium. Verne Lewellen, Packer Corp. general manager, said 35 lockers would be needed for each of two dressing rooms. Nier reported that negotiations are in progress for selling advertising space on a 10-year basis on a strip of the $24,812 scoreboard purchased earlier this month.
LIZ SEES BRIGHTER WORLD AFTER TRADE AT '57 CAMP OPENS
JUL 27 (Stevens Point-Green Bay Press-Gazette) – The world looked brighter to Head Coach Liz Blackbourn as he surveyed the 1957 Packer scene here today. Liz, in the midst of greeting 50-plus athletes at the Packers’ Central State Teachers College training base, said, “I have hopes now that we can mount some kind of offense.” He had reference, of course, to the four new Packers secured in Friday’s historic trade that sent Tobin Rote and Val Joe Walker to Detroit in exchange for tackles Oliver Spencer and Norman Masters, guard-tackle Jim Salsbury and halfback Don McIlhenny. “That switches our weaknesses about a little bit, doesn’t it?” he observed dryly. “Seriously, these additions should give us a reasonably good offensive line – if they all report. If they don’t of course, the deal is off. I don’t anticipate any trouble on that score, though,” Liz said. “Some of them are supposed to be in any minute and I know for sure Salsbury and Masters are on their way now.” Continuing with his evaluation, Blackbourn declared, “These fellows should give us pretty good protection for our passer and good blocking for our runners, in fact, just good offensive go all around. And when we get Ron Kramer from the All-Stars,” he said, permitting himself another peek into the future, “we’ll have good receiving, too, with Gary Knafelc, Bill Howton and Kramer.” He concedes that the loss of Rote is a serious loss but feels the quarterback situation is far from desperate. “We all (Liz and his aides) felt that Bart Starr is a good quarterback,” Blackbourn explained. “On the other hand, we feel that Parilli has to prove himself – to our staff, that is. He has played good ball, though, we know that so I would say we have adequate strength at quarterback.” Liz added he has more urgent concerns. “I’m still worried about our defensive line and our linebackers,” he admitted. In a specific analysis, he observed that the defensive tackle situation is the same as it was a year ago and the linebacker corps depleted by the departure of Deral Teteak and Roger Zatkoff. Blackbourn’s 1957 prospectus followed: CENTER – “Improved. Jim Ringo’s a real good offensive center and Mike Hudock, our draftee from Miami, has a very fine reputation. In fact, he is the offensive center in the All-Star camp right now. Larry Lauer is a very capable substitute. The way it looks now, Ringo will be number one with Hudock and Lauer fighting it out for the No. 2 job.”…GUARD – “Green. Al Barry and Joe Skibinski have played ball but they’re about the only ones with experience here. His size is a little against him but Dalton Truax, the rookie from Georgia Tech, played ball in the North-South game. He’s also one of the top men in the All-Star camp. Pat Hinton from Louisiana State has real good recommendations. Cecil Morris, listed as guard now, probably will be moved to tackle.”…LINEBACKERS – “I’m a little bit fretty about our linebackers. You’ve got to be when you lost two like Deral Teteak and Roger Zatkoff. Of course, we have Tom Bettis and Bill Forester, who have experience, and Sam Palumbo, who has played consistently with the Browns. We’ll just have to battle it out here and see what happens.”…TACKLES – “We should be okay here offensively with the addition of Spencer, Salsbury and Masters. They’ll give us good protection for the passer and good blocking. Our defensive tackles are the same, with Bill Lucky as a third man. Bob Dean, John Macerelli and Len Szafaryn are experienced and Carl Vereen, our rookie from Georgia Tech, is taking over pretty well in the All-Star camp, from what I understand.”…ENDS – “We have our regulars from last year, John Martinkovic and Nate Borden, plus Jim Temp. Jim is not going to be out of service right away, however. We hope he will be able to help us. We also might get something out of a fellow like Don Luft. Jerry Smith will be available here, too. Ken Vakey, Sam Morley, Gary Knafelc, Bill Howton and Ron Kramer should make up an offensive unit that measures up to league standards pretty well. If Max McGee gets out of service in time to help us somewhere along the way, that will be gravy.”…QUARTERBACKS – “We have adequate strength here. The coaches feel Bart Starr is a good quarterback and Parilli, although he has to prove himself to our staff, has played good ball, we know. Paul Hornung will not be considered as a quarterback – eventually he will but not right now. We’ll use him at left half for the most part although we may let him play some quarterback during the exhibition season.”…HALFBACKS – “Our defensive halfbacks have a lot of experience. Fellows like Bobby Dillon, Hank Gremminger. John Petitbon, Glenn Young. Also have Bob Burris. Val Joe Walker is a holdout, of course, and we don’t know whether he will be back or not. Offensively, there hasn’t been too much change. Of the new boys, Lee Hermsen is well-coordinate with plenty of nerve and speed. Credell Green from Washington is a real hard going boy, too, as I understand it. I can’t say too much about Joe Johnson’s competitive ability, either. Al Carmichael and Bill Roberts are back, too. We don’t have too many offensive halfbacks – maybe enough. We might get Tom Pagna out of service – and we might think about getting another halfback somewhere.”…FULLBACKS – “We don’t make too much differentiation between our halfbacks and fullbacks. Aside from Fred Cone and Howie Ferguson, we have a rookie named Ron Quillian from Tulane. He’s a real well-conditioned athlete. According to Doc Erskine, who’s coaching at Louisiana State, ‘he’s the boy who always wins the ball game.’”
WHO'S MORE VALUABLE, QUARTERBACK OR TACKLE?
JUL 27 (Green Bay) - Trade Thoughts: Who is more valuable to a football team – a quarterback or a tackle (or tackles)? Obviously, there is no simple, one-syllable answer to this question, which has many ramifications. Granted that both are required, there often comes a time when a coach is forced to make a choice. The Packers, who in a sense have put their money on the so-called mules up front on the basis of their electrifying trade with Detroit Friday, and the Lions will have at least a partial answer by 4:30 Sunday afternoon, Oct. 6. That, of course, is the date of the first 1957 Packer-Lion meeting in the new stadium. With now ex-Packer Tobin Rote in the Motor City invaders’ lineup, the new Packer palace should be enjoying its second straight sellout (following the Bears Sept. 29). Rote, of course, will be a key figure in the “Great Experiment”. This takes us back to a September afternoon two years ago when the Packers upset the Lions 20-17 at City Stadium with an involuntary assist from a sore-armed Bobby Layne. Lion Coach Buddy Parker, already despairing of the title chances of Detroit’s defending champions, thought it was opening day, told the reporter, “In this league, you have to have three basis things to win. First of all, you have to have a good passing quarterback, then two good pass-receiving ends. You can build around those. If Layne’s arm stays sore, we can’t win it, that’s for sure. That’s how important a good quarterback is.” Parker obviously was operating on that assumption in dealing for Rote since, in order to get the Rice Rifle, he surrendered two starting members of his 1956 forward wall, Jim Salsbury and Oliver Spencer, plus a third tackle with star potential, Norm Masters, and Don McIlhenny, a proven halfback. That would seem like a high price for any football player. A football team also must have some robust fellows in front of that quarterback, or between those ends, if you will, in order to operate effectively. This, of course, was Packer Coach Liz Blackbourn’s concern since he was shy of tackles but, happily, well supplied with quarterbacks – Rote, Vito (Babe) Parilli, Bart Starr and, if needed, Paul Hornung. Although it won’t be conclusive, the Oct. 6 engagement should indicate whether the reinforced Green Bay wall will offset a Rote in Lion’s clothing – and any possible depreciation in Packer QB quality as the result of the tall Texan’s departure. The guess is here that it will. From the Green Bay standpoint, the trade has long-range aspects since all four newcomers are young while Rote, at 29, could well be on the verge of retirement. Should this come to pass in the near future, and the new Packers match their reputations, Friday’s deal may come to rank as the most significant in the Packers’ long history. It could make them a contender again – and a champion!
ROTE TRADED TO IMPROVE PACKER LINE
JULY 27 (Green Bay) - "You have to make a big sacrifice to get what you want," Coach Liz Blackbourn of the Green Bay Packers said Friday in commenting on the trade that sent veteran quarterback Tobin Rote to the Detroit Lions. "We just hope Tobin doesn't come back with Detroit and kill us. Rote's great, real great," Blackbourn said, "but we had a serious line situation here. As in the past we had no assurance rookies could fill the gap." Rote is the key man in the deal that also sent defensive back Val Joe Walker to the Lions in exchange for halfback Don McIlhenny, tackles Oliver Spencer and Norm Masters and guard Jim Salsbury. The Packers, with three quarterbacks in camp, needed line strength while the Lions wanted help for their only signal caller, Bobby Layne. It was the second big deal for the Packers who earlier got six players, five of them defensemen, from the Cleveland Browns for linebacker Roger Zatkoff and quarterback Bobby Garrett. Signal callers on hand today as the Packers opened training at Stevens Point State College were Bart Starr and Babe Parilli, who was acquired in the Cleveland trade. The Packers also have on hand Notre Dame quarterback sensation Paul Hornung, who will report for halfback duties after the College All-Star game. Walker has insisted he is through with professional football and Blackbourn said that if he does not report to the Lions and if Masters, a rookie, makes the Green Bay squad, the Packers will give the Lions an undisclosed draft choice.